NJ bar pie 🍺
The NJ bar pies we checked are Star Tavern in Orange and Kinchley's Tavern in Ramsey: small, super-thin pies, both $$.
Small. Super thin. Share it.
No wasted trip. See the spot, the $, and go.
We never make up ratings. Miles come from street addresses.
Tap Maps or Waze. Or Find my pizza.
Where to go
- Orange, NJ · bar pie icon
Star Tavern
📍 400 High St, Orange, NJ 07050$$ · Thin Jersey bar pie. Busy on weekends.🕒 Hours
- Mon11 AM – 9 PM
- Tue11 AM – 10 PM
- Wed11 AM – 10 PM
- Thu11 AM – 10 PM
- Fri11 AM – 10 PM
- Sat11 AM – 10 PM
- Sun12 PM – 9 PM
Hours checked Sep 26, 2026 · source: startavern.net
Hours can change — call ahead · 📞 (973) 675-3336
- Ramsey, NJ
Kinchley's Tavern
📍 586 Franklin Tpke, Ramsey, NJ 07446$$ · Ultra-thin bar pies. Cash only.🕒 Hours
- Mon11 AM – 10 PM
- Tue11 AM – 10 PM
- Wed11 AM – 10 PM
- Thu11 AM – 10 PM
- Fri11 AM – 11 PM
- Sat11 AM – 11 PM
- Sun12 PM – 10 PM
ℹ️ Cash only.
Hours checked Sep 26, 2026 · source: kinchleyspizza.com
Hours can change — call ahead · 📞 (201) 934-7777
Styles here
Quick answers
Where is the best bar pie in New Jersey?
We don't rank by stars. Our checked spots: Star Tavern (400 High St, Orange) and Kinchley's Tavern (586 Franklin Tpke, Ramsey).
What is a NJ bar pie?
A small, super-thin, cracker-crust pie with cheese to the edge, made to share at the bar.
Do I need cash?
Our card for Kinchley's says cash only. Check before you go.
Why trust PIZZA OG?
We check every spot by hand on official sites and map listings. We never make up ratings or reviews. On Find my pizza, miles are counted from each spot's street address.
More guides
Last updated . Spots checked by hand on official sites and map listings (Sep 2026). Hours change: check Maps before you go.